• Focus News EU is an independent media based in Europe
  • providing the world's latest news, the definitive source for independent journalism from every corner of the globe.

There Are Good Alternatives to Teacher Strikes

World Emily 2weeks ago (12-02) 27Views 0Comments

More Bank Runs Worry Chinese Regulators, Investors

News Analysis Warning signs are flashing all over China’s banking sector. Chinese regulators have seized and bailed out lenders at an unprecedented pace amidst a surge in bad debt all the while forcing banks to step up lending at increasingly lower interest spreads. It’s a way to keep banks in business but not a recipe for future longevity. Increasing worries about the health of China’s financial system have hit investor confidence in banks and hurt recent capital raising efforts as well. I wrote in August that after three Chinese bank bailouts in three months, more will follow. After a few months of calm, two local bank runs in November have added fuel to the fire. Yingkou Coastal Bank is the latest to suffer a bank run. Yingkou faced a “flash…

There Are Good Alternatives to Teacher Strikes

The relationship between the Ontario teachers’ unions and Premier Doug Ford’s government has gone from bad to toxic. Upset with the government’s education policies, the Elementary Teachers’ Federation of Ontario and the Ontario Secondary School Teachers’ Federation (OSSTF) recently began work-to-rule campaigns.

During work-to-rule campaigns, teachers refuse to write report card comments, attend professional development sessions, or respond to emails from school administrators outside of school hours. Teachers are also holding information pickets in front of schools, and they are handing out flyers to parents before and after school. Fortunately, teachers have not withdrawn from student extracurricular activities, so the impact of this job action on students has so far been minimal.

However, there is a real possibility that job action will escalate from the withdrawal of these services to a full-blown strike in which schools close down. Teachers are already planning to walk off the job for a day on Dec. 4 if a deal is not reached.

Neither the government nor the teachers’ unions have shown any signs of backing down from this conflict. If a strike happens, students and parents will feel the impact the most.

To be clear, teachers have legitimate reasons for their concerns. For example, the government’s stubborn insistence that all high school students must complete two e-learning courses has zero evidence supporting their educational impact. No other jurisdiction in North America requires students to complete two e-learning courses as a condition for graduation. It appears that these mandatory courses are simply an awkward cost-cutting exercise.

Nevertheless, strikes are a poor way to resolve collective bargaining impasses between governments and teachers. Not only are parents forced to make alternative child-care arrangements, students miss out on valuable class time and their learning suffers. There are only a limited number of days in the school year and it is nearly impossible to make up for the lost learning time.

Class time matters because research shows that important skills such as reading comprehension and critical thinking are linked closely to background knowledge. While many people assume that reading is a transferable skill that is independent of content, the reality is that background knowledge about a topic is the best predictor of a student’s ability to read and understand material about the topic. Similarly, students can only think critically about things that they already know something about. In other words, critical thinking cannot take place in the absence of substantial content knowledge.

Because of their need for background knowledge, class time is a valuable commodity for all students. Teachers are fundamental providers of this knowledge, and depriving students of their teachers for a long time sets them back in their reading and critical thinking skills. In addition, for many students who come from disadvantaged homes, school is a place of stability and security. It is unfair to deprive these students of the relationships they have with their teachers.

This doesn’t mean that teachers should unilaterally lay down their arms and surrender to whatever dictates come from their employer. Not only would this be unfair, it would lead to a lower quality of education for students. Provincial governments and school boards often promote education fads (such as mandatory e-learning) that sound great but don’t work in practice. Teachers are on the front lines of teaching and learning and they deserve to have their voices heard.

There are two provinces where teacher strikes cannot happen because they’re illegal—Manitoba and Prince Edward Island. In Manitoba, the teachers’ union voluntarily gave up their right-to-strike during the 1950s in exchange for binding arbitration, teacher tenure, and a provincial certification board. Since then, all impasses in collective bargaining have been resolved by binding arbitration. Today, Manitoba teachers enjoy similar salaries and benefits as their Ontario colleagues—without ever having to walk a picket line.

One objection to binding arbitration in Ontario is that the provincial government could overrule arbitration rulings. However, all provincial governments can already order striking workers back to work and impose a collective agreement. In 2015, Kathleen Wynne’s Liberal government used back-to-work legislation to end a six-week strike of high school teachers in three school boards. No provincial government will stand idly by while students lose a substantial part of the school year.

As for resisting the useless fads often imposed by employers, the OSSTF is already doing some important work in this area. Last year, OSSTF sponsored researchED, a teacher professional development conference that is put on by teachers for teachers. Many of the presenters at the researchED conferences are at the forefront of pushing against the most useless fads foisted on teachers and students. Even before researchED came along, OSSTF spoke out strongly against a no-zero policy imposed by the provincial government, which was finally dropped.

Obviously, teachers are in a stronger position to speak out against silly fads when they are in classrooms than when they are standing in picket lines. Thus, it is possible for teachers to advance their interests without going on strike.

Students and parents deserve the stability of knowing that teachers will be in school for the entire school year.

Michael Zwaagstra is a public high school teacher and author of “A Sage on the Stage: Common Sense Reflections on Teaching and Learning.”

Views expressed in this article are the opinions of the author and do not necessarily reflect the views of The Epoch Times.

This article is from the Internet:There Are Good Alternatives to Teacher Strikes

380,000 Hongkongers March to Renew Calls for Freedom and Democracy

Protesters could be heard shouting slogans such as “disband the police force,” and “the heavens will eliminate the Chinese Communist Party, let the entire Party die.” The peaceful march, which was organized by a local netizen who identified himself as Swing, had been granted police approval. But soon after it took off, police interrupted the scene. A sizable force had gathered, with at least nine police vans in the area. At around 4:50 p.m. local time, riot police suddenly charged at protesters at an area near the intersection between Salisbury Road and Nathan Road, which is right before Salisbury Garden. The police fired pepper spray and tear gas, before making at least two arrests. The police then put up a blue flag, declaring that people are engaging in an illegal…


The article is from the Internet, and the content does not represent the position of this website.丨This website usesBY-NC-SAagreement for authorization
please indicate the link for reprint:There Are Good Alternatives to Teacher Strikes
Likes (0)
Post my comment
Cancel comment

Hi,You need to fill in your nickname and email address!

  • Nickname (Required)
  • Email (Required)
  • Link