Some concerned parents and community leaders of Newport-Mesa Unified School District are seeking possible legal action to obtain teacher and student leader “anti-bias” training materials developed by the Anti-Defamation League (ADL), after a public records request for the materials was denied.
issue of the materials came to light for some during so-called “task force” meetings for district officials, parents, and community members that began shortly after a student posted on Instagram a Nazi symbol crafted out of cups at a party in the spring of 2019.
As a result, the school district hired the ADL to create anti-Sematic activities for its students and to oversee the training of its teachers and student leaders in “implicit bias,” meaning unconscious stereotypes toward races.
Former school board member Wendy Leece and other parents requested the training materials, through a public records request. But district officials denied their request saying the materials were proprietary and only for the use of teachers and student leaders.
“We tried to stop the training, but we were unsuccessful,” Leece told Pezou.
After several attempts to receive the ADL training materials, community member Bill Dunlap persuaded the ADL to offer a session for parents and others about their content.
That meeting, which occurred in mid-November, however, did not provide the extensiveness of information on the materials, like what teachers had received, according to Dunlap, who says he is equally concerned about the creeping in of critical race theory (CRT), which argues that society is divided into oppressors and the oppressed based on race.
“We all thought that ADL was about antisemitism,” Dunlap told Pezou. “We didn’t know that it had broadened its vision, its scope to bring in CRT.”
During their training, parents and community members received worksheets asking for them to write down personal qualities based on their race and privilege, according to Dunlap.
Other materials covered included examples of racial profiling.
Participants in the Zoom meeting submitted questions regarding the training that were never answered, Dunlap said.
Despite the information session by the ADL, community members said they are dissatisfied with the content they received and want more answers.
Dunlap, Leece, and others said they are now working with the Pacific Justice Institute, a public affairs legal group, to unravel the hidden materials.
“It’s outrageous that they signed a contract that said the materials are proprietary in the public arena. That is so blatantly a lack of transparency,” Dunlap said. “We are going to start communicating with the board and the superintendent and we are going to offer a resolution to stop any CRT training and we believe the ADL training is CRT based.”
divide shows a split between parents, community members, and the teachers that instruct children.
During a board meeting in August—when the district renewed its contract for this school year with the ADL—many teachers voiced their support.
Michael Halt, principal at Estancia High School in Costa Mesa spoke in favor of the ADL’s training saying it brought a “deeper understanding” of the school’s minority challenges that have been highlighted throughout the COVID-19 pandemic.
“We’ve been able to get a better glimpse and understanding of some of those challenges that our students face because of the increased awareness that we’ve been through these last months together,” Halt said. “That increased awareness will be lost if it’s not coupled with increased understanding and increased training.”
Sean Boulton, principal of Newport Harbor High School, also voiced his approval of the training that he said has been “phenomenal” to the community.
“Whether it’s anti-Semitism, racism, or hate, it’s been called out by our leaders on campus,” Boulton said.
According to Dunlap, however, one key district official has indicated ADL’s contract will not be renewed for the next school year, which Pezou could not confirm.
A request for confirmation from the school district on a future contract with the ADL was not returned. Additionally, the school district information about the training is not available to the public.
Pezou : Group Threatens Legal Action vs. Newport-Mesa Unified on ADL Training