Canadian Pension Money Keeps Pouring Into China as Risks Escalate

Missing Mexican Lawmaker’s Body Found Following Abduction

MEXICO CITY—The body of a missing Mexican congresswoman from the western state of Colima has been found in a hidden grave more than a month after armed men abducted her, President Andrés Manuel López Obrador said on June 3. López Obrador expressed his condolences to the family of Anel Bueno, a 38-year-old legislator from his Morena party. Armed men took Bueno on April 29 while she was promoting health measures to prevent the spread of the CCP (Chinese Communist Party) virus in Ixtlahuacán, Colima. During a morning news conference in Campeche, along Mexico’s Gulf coast, the president said her body had been found Tuesday and that one suspect was in custody. The Colima state prosecutor’s office had not yet commented on the discovery of her body. “We still don’t know…

News Analysis

The Canada Pension Plan Investment Board (CPPIB) runs one of the world’s largest pension funds, with assets of $409.6 billion on March 31, as per its 2020 annual report. It and two other big Canadian pension funds, including the Ontario Teachers’ Pension Plan, remain strongly bullish on China despite plenty of reasons not to be.

Aside from a number of geopolitical risks, particular challenges with investing in Chinese companies are that some pose national security concerns or may be complicit in human rights violations. They have also been criticized for not being transparent in their financial reporting, and according to Chinese law, may be called upon to serve the needs of the Chinese Communist Party (CCP) at any time.

Another issue is barriers to liquidating investments in China and repatriating the funds.

“The most recent change in tone and aggression of the Beijing government would cause any board to be reviewing its risk analysis,” Liberal MP John McKay told The Epoch Times.

“It’s a far riskier investment. I don’t know how you can arrive with any other conclusion,” he added. “The political risk has changed, so also has the investment risk.”

Chinese law prohibits oversight by foreign entities of the reporting of Chinese companies, creating a worrying lack of transparency for financial markets regulators. The United States is taking steps to institute a level playing field for companies listed on its exchanges by delisting Chinese companies that don’t comply with regulatory requirements, like Luckin Coffee.

Questionable Choices

The CPPIB said in 2018 that it aimed to ramp up investments in China to 20 percent by 2025, even as annual Canadian investment in China has been declining since peaking in 2008.

The CPPIB reported nearly $15 billion (4 percent of the fund) is held in Chinese currency—the renminbi.

At its fiscal year-end on March 31, the CPPIB held Alibaba shares worth $2.5 billion—its then-largest holding of a single company. The CPPIB has reportedly since accumulated $2.7 billion in another large Chinese company—Tencent—the social media giant that runs WeChat.

Tencent has assisted Beijing in censorship and surveillance, facilitating its human rights abuses, while WeChat is controlled by the CCP and actively spreads disinformation while suppressing information that’s critical of the Party.

In its annual report, the CPPIB highlighted a US$375 million investment in Tencent Music Entertainment Group, an online music platform operator in China.

Conservative MP Garnett Genuis said some checks are needed to ensure that the investments don’t support a company that violates human rights.

“When Canadians have their automatic pension contributions made, they don’t want their money to be put into gross violations of human rights against their will,” he said in a March 16 interview with The Epoch Times.

Genuis said he could invite the pension board to one of the Special Committee on Canada-China Relations parliamentary meetings.

“That’s something we can explore, because we need to make sure that these things aren’t happening and don’t happen again in China and in other places as well.”

The CPPIB’s investments in two Chinese companies that make video surveillance equipment—Hangzhou Hikvision and Zhejiang Dahua—drew criticism from Conservative MP Tom Kmiec last year over their roles in the suppression of Uyghur Muslims.

Both companies are on the U.S. Department of Commerce’s entity list—a list of parties deemed to pose a major risk to national security or foreign policy interests.

The CPPIB told The Epoch Times that they decline to comment when asked if it owns stock in those two Chinese companies.

It was also a major participant in Baixin Bank’s recent stock issuance, according to Chinese media.

China’s banking system is rife with bad loans, and their banks are beholden to the CCP and not their investors, according to a May 27 report by the U.S.-China Economic and Security Review Commission.

“Despite four decades of promised liberalization, the Communist Party-state retains the ability to intervene decisively in China’s banking system to achieve desired outcomes,” begins the report’s summary.

This could take the form of lending to unprofitable state-owned enterprises and running the risk of more bad loans—a conflict of interest that jeopardizes returns for investors.

‘House of Cards’

Beijing desperately wants to hold on to U.S. dollars to buy raw materials and make overseas purchases.

Coinciding with more Chinese nationals and foreign businesses wanting to move money out of China, foreign lenders are less willing to supply U.S. dollars to the slowing Chinese economy. And by design, the Sino-U.S. trade war doesn’t help China either as it impairs the country’s ability to export to the United States and receive dollars.

The renminbi is near its weakest level against the U.S. dollar since early 2008. It is caught in a vicious circle as authorities try to stimulate the economy by lowering interest rates, which also reduces the currency’s value.

As of late 2016, firms that wanted to exchange renminbi into U.S. dollars needed approval for any transactions greater than US$5 million. Back then, the European Chamber of Commerce in China told The Wall Street Journal that it was aware of many cases where the new regulatory scrutiny is disruptive to companies’ operations and “exacerbates uncertainties regarding the predictability of China’s investment environment.”

Hayman Capital Management founder Kyle Bass called the Chinese economy a “house of cards” in an interview with American Thought Leaders, a program hosted by The Epoch Times. He mentioned a large unnamed public company that has US$10 billion in cash on its balance sheet. Of that money, US$1.5 billion is in China, and the company has been unable to get it out for four years.

“And so, this is what I worry about: Our pensions and all of the money that China has figured out how to coerce MSCI [Morgan Stanley Capital International] and the various index providers … to weigh China so heavily,” he said.

Bass has long been critical of foreign investments in China propping up the communist state’s economy.

A common strategy for international investing is driven by mimicking indices such as the MSCI Emerging Markets Index, which began including China’s A shares—mainland stocks quoted in renminbi—in 2018 and now has a one-third allocation to China, its largest.

“The investments are clearly at risk of increased scrutiny by the government Beijing. And that will never go well for the investor,” McKay said. “It’s not expropriation, but it is a subtle assertion of power and control over reasonable expectations.”

The Canadian Chamber of Commerce told The Epoch Times that its members hadn’t raised the issue of trouble repatriating funds from China thus far.

Focus News: Canadian Pension Money Keeps Pouring Into China as Risks Escalate

Bank of Canada Keeps Key Rate Target On Hold, Expects Return to Growth in Q3

OTTAWA鈥擳he economy appears to have avoided a worst-case scenario due to the COVID-19 pandemic, the Bank of Canada said Wednesday as it kept its key interest rate steady at its lower bound. The bank left its target for the overnight rate unchanged at 0.25 percent, which it has said is as low as it will go. The bank also tinkered with some programs designed to ease the flow of credit, pointing to improving indicators in the market and the economy overall. Overall, the central bank said Wednesday it believes the impact of the pandemic on the global economy has peaked, but hedged the outlook by warning of a high level of uncertainty about how the recovery will unfold. Since the pandemic struck Canada and public health restrictions put a freeze…